Surveying the (non)experts

A recent survey of over 400 television meteorologists provides some insight into the views of an important group. Many people think that television weather forecasters and climate scientists are basically the same thing, so meteorologists are viewed as experts on climate change. That can be problematic ( like Joe Bastardi, for example, whom I mentioned a while back), because the two groups are not at all as similar as the public suspects.

As the survey indicates, 34% of tv meteorologists have a bachelor’s degree in meteorology. 10% have a B.S. in another Earth science, and 9% have a master’s degree in either meteorology or another Earth science. That leaves 47% who have degrees in journalism, communication, or something else. While there’s some overlap between meteorology and climate science, they are fundamentally different fields. The vast majority of these people  just don’t have the background to really engage climate research. That’s not to say they’re incapable to making judgments, it just means they aren’t the experts the public perceives them to be. It’s not insulting to point out that a pharmacist is not a heart surgeon.

On to the interest results:
83% agree that the climate is warming, but 29% think the warming is “caused mostly by natural events”. We’ll come back to the 17% that don’t agree.

First, only 18% of those surveyed correctly recognize that >90% of climate scientists agree that warming is happening and caused by humans. Among meteorologists who agree warming is human-caused, 58% recognized this. Among those who believe warming is caused by natural events, only 10% recognize it.
A total of 23% think half or fewer of climate scientists agree that warming is human-caused.
Unfortunately, none of the rest of the questions asked of the “yes, the climate is warming” crowd are terribly interesting.

So back to the 17% who don’t agree that the climate is warming- 9% think the climate is NOT warming (the survey calls them the Unconvinced), and the other 8% don’t know (the Undecideds). Their reasoning is revealing…
The Unconvinced certainly don’t care for climate models much (what a shock!)- 87% say they are based on inadequate data, and 81% think they’re based on flawed assumptions.

But then we go down the rabbit hole…
Among the Undecideds, 41% believe claims of global warming are a “cover for a political agenda to increase government control of society”, and another 24% don’t know if that’s the case or not. Among the Unconvinced, a full 70% believe this is the case.
Similarly, only 13% of the Undecideds and 24% of the Unconvinced did not agree with the baffling idea that claims of global warming are a cover to ensure that researchers continue to receive grants.
72% of Undecideds and 90% of the Unconvinced say they distrust the motives of climate scientists. That’s pretty remarkable.

Only 6% of Undecideds and 3% of the Unconvinved correctly disagreed with the statement that “climate scientists have been caught changing their results to make climate change appear more certain than it is”, which refers primarily to the unimaginatively-named “climategate” scandal involving Penn State’s Michael Mann and researchers at the University of East Anglia. Those researchers have been cleared of any dishonesty or wrong-doing by NINE separate independent investigations now.

But perhaps this is the most incredible (and telling) result in the whole thing:
Only 56% of Undecideds and 47% of the Unconvinced were willing to disagree that “the belief that humans could influence the climate system is hubris- the Earth’s climate is in God’s hands.” That blows me away. They believe it is literally impossible to affect the climate system. It’s absolutely no wonder, then, that they are unimpressed by all the evidence that demonstrates we are doing exactly that…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s